While antique wall telephones may appear to be alike at first glance, and many of them do have the same components within their wooden cases, there are variations from phone to phone that can make a big difference in how much they are worth. By learning about the different details and styles of early wall units made between the late 1800s and the early 1930s, you will be able to determine their value. Early two box phones were made by companies such as Western Electric, The Williams Electric Co., Connecticut, and Couch & Seeley. The shapes of the boxes varied slightly from maker to maker, but they all held the same basic type of local battery components inside. Values are influenced by the condition of the phone and any unusual components that may be incorporated, such as receivers other than standard pony models (like a milk bottle receiver), glass or plastic windows on the boxes, or mouthpieces that differ from the normal black transmitter. Most are made of oak, so finding a two box wall phone made of another type of wood like walnut can add value as well. Most two box telephones sell in the $125-450 range.
Walnut Two Box Wall Telephone
The walnut two box wall telephone pictured was made around 1900 and manufactured by The Williams Electric Co. It has a milk bottle receiver marked OST. Not shown are the two glass battery jars housed in the bottom box which are cracked in back. The unit measures 32 inches tall and its overall condition was deemed excellent by the selling auction house. This telephone sold at Morphy Auctions in June 2012 for $360 plus buyer’s premium. The first Fiddleback phones produced their own alternating current for power using a magneto, or small electric generator that was powered as the phone was cranked, and the direct currents needed to operate them came from batteries housed within the phones. Early examples powered like this are referenced as “local battery” phones. The Bell System came out with the Western Electric No. 85 Fiddleback, which did not require batteries or a magneto because it was powered with the electricity from the local telephone company, as are our landline telephones today. The transmitters, or mouthpieces, and receivers used with Fiddlebacks are often similar to later phones, but the overall shape of the back and box are very different from more common Picture Frame Front and Plain Front wooden wall phones. Even though these were made for a shorter period of time and are a bit more unusual than Picture Frame and Plain Front models, they sell for similar prices usually in the $100-450 range depending on the condition. Unusual components and some variations of the style raise the value, which is true for most types of antique phones.
Couch & Seeley Mini Fiddleback
The phone pictured is an oak Couch & Seeley Mini Fiddleback intercom model. In addition to serving as a telephone, it also operated as an intercom using the buttons below the transmitter (mouthpiece). It has a single gong ringer (where most early wall phones have two), and a traditional unmarked pony style receiver. It measures 17 inches tall and its width is smaller in comparison to most Fiddleback models, which makes it “mini.” This phone sold for $300 in June 2012 at Morphy Auctions plus buyer’s premium. These phones are “local battery” phones that get their power to operate when cranked to activate a magneto, and they also require batteries to make them functional. Many companies made Picture Frame Front wall phones including Western Electric, Couch, and Century from the early 1900s through the 1930s. The example shown here is one of the earliest versions of the Western Electric model 317 phone. The back has an arched top where line terminals are attached. Collectors refer to this as a “cathedral” top. This phone came with a standard pony receiver. The first doors on these models were hinged to open left to right but this interfered with the magneto crank, so later versions opened right to left instead. The following generation of Picture Frame Front phones eliminated exposed terminals as well and was made without cathedral top backs. Most Picture Frame Fronts are made of oak, but they can occasionally be found crafted of other woods. Writing platforms vary slightly in size and slant from model to model and maker to maker just as with Plain Front phones. Values vary depending on the cosmetic condition and whether or not the phone is in operating order. Collectors also value phones that are as original as possible with few reproduction parts used when they are restored. Most Picture Frame Front phones sell in the $100-$400 range.
Western Electric Picture Frame Front
This Western Electric Picture Frame Front telephone dates to 1907. The oak cabinet has the original paper wiring diagram inside. The phone measures 24 inches tall and sold for $150 (plus buyer’s premium) by Morphy Auctions in June 2012. Many companies made Plain Front wall phones including American Electric, Western Electric, Kellogg, and Stromberg-Carlson through the 1930s when phone styles began to shift dramatically to more modern-looking designs. Most Plain Fronts are made of oak, but they can occasionally be found crafted of other woods. Standard pony receivers, which were often black, are commonly found with these phones. Transmitters can be either long or short and have marked or unmarked faceplates. Writing platforms vary slightly in size and slant from model to model and maker to maker. Values vary depending on condition, whether or not the phone is in working order, and unusual components that may be present like coin boxes, and of course, having good provenance can help. If a phone came from a historic building, for instance, that can add to the value. Most Plain Front phones sell in the $100-$400 range.
American Electric Plain Front
This American Electric Plain Front telephone was made around 1910. The cabinet is oak and marked with the American Electric shield nameplate. The transmitter base is also in the shape of a shield and the hook has shield cutouts on each side. The pony style receiver is also marked American Electric. This phone measures 20 1/2 inches tall and was in excellent condition. It sold for $120 (not including buyer’s premium) by Morphy Auctions in June 2012.
